Leeseberg & Valentine

Penthouse One 175 South Third Street Columbus, OH 43215

A Reputation Built By Success
Call For A Free Consultation
Toll Free: 800-976-2226 | Local: 614-221-2223

Translation services available.

Practice Areas

Wrongful life: Can medical providers be sued for failing to honor advance directives?

Most people know that medical providers can be sued for harm caused by mistakes, as well as for injuries caused by abuse or neglect.

But what about injuries caused by a refusal to honor an advance directive calling for a patient to be allowed to die, rather than being kept alive through ventilators or other extraordinary interventions?

In this post, we will use a Q & A format to address this important question.

Are there really cases where medical providers are being sued for using aggressive interventions that went against patients' advance medical directives?

Yes. In several cases around the country, families whose loved ones were left in terrible condition after directives against aggressive treatments were disregarded are suing for damages.

A recent New York Times article highlighted some of the cases.

Can you give an example of these cases?

In a case in Maryland, an 83-year-old woman suffered a bad stroke that led to two weeks of hospitalization. She had an advance directive against aggressive life-sustaining interventions and also had named her husband as her proxy for health care decisions if she was unable to make them.

Her husband and four children agreed, after an excruciating family meeting, that if the woman's heart or lungs failed, she should be allowed to die. The husband executed a form on Medical Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment (MOLST) to that effect.

Despite the family's clear intent, hospital staff ignored the MOLST directive. They revived the woman with epinephrine injections and electric shocks, breaking her ribs and damaging her lungs. The intervention left her in much worse shape than before, unable to care for herself.

Does Ohio have the MOLST form and what is it supposed to do?

Yes, Ohio has Medical Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment. This form is supposed to be a medical order that becomes part of a patient's file. The intent is to implement the advance directive that many people include as part of their estate plan.

Our Recent Blog Posts

  • Jan 08 : Did your doctor fail to meet the appropriate standard of care?
    When you learn that you have a medical condition that needs attention, you certainly want to ensure that you not only receive the best care but also receive the correct treatment. Substandard care, misdiagnoses, improper treatments and other medical malpractice...
  • Dec 30 : Did you leave the operating room with more than just stitches?
    The ordeal of having surgery is a big concern on its own. One thing you shouldn't have to worry about is leaving the operating room with more than just the stitches you expected; yet, for many Ohio patients every year,...
Read More Blog Posts

Our Awards

Best Lawyers | Best Law Firms | U.S. News & World Report | 2018 Columbus Lawyer Finder Member | Columbus Bar Association | Columbus Lawyer Finder.com AVVO Rating 10.0 | Superb | Top Attorney Personal Injury AVVO Rating 10.0 | Superb | Top Attorney Medical Malpractice Super lawyers 2005-2017